Appears in exhibition catalog as entry no. 27 (Sale info: $400.00).
"b. Pittsburgh, Pa., 1842. Studied with George Hetzel, Pittsburgh, and afterward, in France, with E. Lambinet, 1862- 1864. Studied in Rome in 1865, and again in Paris in 1866-67 and '68." [P. 9.]
Illustrated Catalogue of Works of Art in the Art Building of the Southern Exposition at Louisville, Ky. August 16 - October 25, 1884. Prepared by Charles M. Kurtz, Director of the Art Department. Editor of National Academy Notes and the Art Union Magazine. Published for the Art Committee by John P. Morton and Company.