Ships and drawing generally, excellent; the water inferior, hard and cut up. There was one small landscape beautiful and sparkling, with much more transparency of color and breadth of effect. A Silver Medal. [Pp. 22-23.]
The Second Exhibition of the Massachusetts Charitable Mechanic Association, at Quincy Hall, in the City of Boston. September 23, 1839. Boston: Published by Isaac R. Butts, for the Association. 1839.