Appears in exhibition catalog as entry no. [not numbered]
Of the pictures entered for competition, none are preeminently qualified as entitled to the medal for the "best painting," though there are several pictures that the Committee deem worthy of nomination as the best in their respective branches of art. In default of any painting of superior excellence entered for competition being found in the Exhibition, the committee would respectfully recommend that the Medal at their disposal be given to the painting by Toby Rosenthal ("Affection's Last Offering") an artist of San Francisco, now residing in Munich. This picture we understand arrived too late to be entered for competition. [P. 59.]
Report of the Sixth Industrial Exhibition of the Mechanics' Institute of the City of San Francisco, held at the Pavilion of the Institute, Union Square, from the 8th of August to the 12th of September, A.D. 1868. San Francisco: Woman's Co-Operative Union Print, 517 Clay Street, 1868.